This guide compares ten pizzerias serving Baltimore, MD while preserving the original article's companies and order. It is designed for shortlisting, not as a claim that every option was personally tested. Compare current credentials, written terms, total cost, availability and the category-specific questions below before choosing.
Quick comparison of 10 pizzerias
| # | Company | Published location | Published phone | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pizza John's | Baltimore, MD | 4106877733 | Website |
| 2 | Isabella's Brick Oven | Baltimore, MD | 410-962-8888 | Website |
| 3 | Di Pasquale's Italian Marketplace & Deli | Baltimore, MD | 410-276-6787 | Website |
| 4 | Joe Squared Pizza & Bar | Baltimore, MD | (410) 545-0444 | Website |
| 5 | Matthew's Pizzeria | Baltimore, MD | 4102768755 | Website |
| 6 | Pasta Mista | Baltimore, MD | 410-327-8855 | Website |
| 7 | HomeSlyce | Baltimore, MD | (410) 616-4360 | Website |
| 8 | Scittino's Italian Market Place | Baltimore, MD | 410-788-2369 | Website |
| 9 | Verde | Baltimore, MD | (410) 522-1000 | Website |
| 10 | Iggies | Baltimore, MD | +1 410-528-0818 | Website |
How this guide was refreshed
This August 16, 2026 editorial rebuild preserves the ten names and their original order. The order is not a newly calculated quality ranking. Maryland Recommendations did not hire, test or independently audit every listed business. Payment does not purchase rank, remove cautions or guarantee visibility. The useful contribution is a consistent comparison framework, clearer contact data, official verification resources and questions readers can use before committing.
Compare styles, dietary options, ordering and group-dining details. Every reader's priorities differ, so shortlist two or three options and ask each one the same questions. Written answers are easier to compare than promotional claims or star ratings alone.
The 10 pizzerias in this guide
1. Pizza John's
Pizza John’s is retained from the original Maryland Recommendations list. Use the published details below as a starting point, then confirm is the current menu available online and how are allergies and cross-contact handled. Availability, staff, services, prices and policies can change, so obtain current written information before booking, signing or paying.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: 4106877733
Website: Visit the company website
2. Isabella's Brick Oven
Consider Isabella’s Brick Oven as one option for pizza dining. During the first conversation, confirm how are allergies and cross-contact handled. Before making a decision, also ask are reservations or deposits required. This page does not claim first-hand testing or guarantee service quality; the listing is a contact and comparison aid.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: 410-962-8888
Website: Visit the company website
3. Di Pasquale's Italian Marketplace & Deli
Di Pasquale’s Italian Marketplace & Deli appears here in the original article’s order, not as the result of a paid position or a hidden quality score. Compare the business on the same criteria used for every listing: are reservations or deposits required, which fees, gratuities or minimums apply, written terms and current contact information.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: 410-276-6787
Website: Visit the company website
4. Joe Squared Pizza & Bar
Joe Squared Pizza & Bar is retained from the original Maryland Recommendations list. Use the published details below as a starting point, then confirm which fees, gratuities or minimums apply and is the current menu available online. Availability, staff, services, prices and policies can change, so obtain current written information before booking, signing or paying.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: (410) 545-0444
Website: Visit the company website
5. Matthew's Pizzeria
Consider Matthew’s Pizzeria as one option for pizza dining. During the first conversation, confirm is the current menu available online. Before making a decision, also ask how are allergies and cross-contact handled. This page does not claim first-hand testing or guarantee service quality; the listing is a contact and comparison aid.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: 4102768755
Website: Visit the company website
6. Pasta Mista
Pasta Mista appears here in the original article’s order, not as the result of a paid position or a hidden quality score. Compare the business on the same criteria used for every listing: how are allergies and cross-contact handled, are reservations or deposits required, written terms and current contact information.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: 410-327-8855
Website: Visit the company website
7. HomeSlyce
HomeSlyce is retained from the original Maryland Recommendations list. Use the published details below as a starting point, then confirm are reservations or deposits required and which fees, gratuities or minimums apply. Availability, staff, services, prices and policies can change, so obtain current written information before booking, signing or paying.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: (410) 616-4360
Website: Visit the company website
8. Scittino's Italian Market Place
Consider Scittino’s Italian Market Place as one option for pizza dining. During the first conversation, confirm which fees, gratuities or minimums apply. Before making a decision, also ask is the current menu available online. This page does not claim first-hand testing or guarantee service quality; the listing is a contact and comparison aid.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: 410-788-2369
Website: Visit the company website
9. Verde
Verde appears here in the original article’s order, not as the result of a paid position or a hidden quality score. Compare the business on the same criteria used for every listing: is the current menu available online, how are allergies and cross-contact handled, written terms and current contact information.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: (410) 522-1000
Website: Visit the company website
10. Iggies
Iggies is retained from the original Maryland Recommendations list. Use the published details below as a starting point, then confirm how are allergies and cross-contact handled and are reservations or deposits required. Availability, staff, services, prices and policies can change, so obtain current written information before booking, signing or paying.
Published location: Baltimore, MD
Published phone: +1 410-528-0818
Website: Visit the company website
How to compare your shortlist
Current menu and dietary information
Ask is the current menu available online. Request a specific answer tied to your project, appointment, purchase or visit rather than relying on a general promise. Record the response so every option is judged consistently.
Hours, reservations and service format
Ask how are allergies and cross-contact handled. Request a specific answer tied to your project, appointment, purchase or visit rather than relying on a general promise. Record the response so every option is judged consistently.
Food-safety inspection information
Ask are reservations or deposits required. Request a specific answer tied to your project, appointment, purchase or visit rather than relying on a general promise. Record the response so every option is judged consistently.
Total price, fees and accessibility
Ask which fees, gratuities or minimums apply. Request a specific answer tied to your project, appointment, purchase or visit rather than relying on a general promise. Record the response so every option is judged consistently.
Official sources and independent verification
Use primary sources for credentials, consumer protections and category rules. A business website or directory profile is not a substitute for an official record.
A practical selection checklist
- Define the exact outcome, location, timing and budget before contacting anyone.
- Shortlist at least two or three options that appear to serve the need.
- Verify applicable licenses, credentials, insurance or inspection records using the official sources above.
- Ask every option the same category-specific questions and keep the answers.
- Request written scope, exclusions, total charges, payment timing and cancellation terms.
- Confirm who performs the work or service and who handles problems afterward.
- Read the final agreement before paying a deposit or authorizing work.
Related Maryland guides
Frequently asked questions
How should I shortlist pizza places in Baltimore?
Start with the ten published options, remove businesses that do not match your location or need, then compare two or three on the same questions. Verify current credentials where applicable, request written terms and confirm who will actually provide the service. Convenience matters, but it should not replace documentation and fit.
What should I verify before choosing?
Check current hours and menus directly, and consult the relevant local health department for food-facility oversight information.
What should a written estimate or agreement include?
For events or group dining, a useful quote identifies menu, headcount, service charges, taxes, gratuity, deposits, cancellation terms and allergy procedures.
Should I choose only by price or online reviews?
No. Price and reviews are useful signals, but neither proves current fit, licensing, availability or contract quality. Compare the complete scope, exclusions, responsible provider, total cost, policies, communication and verification records. Treat unusually vague or urgent sales pressure as a reason to slow down and request documentation.
How current are these pizzerias details?
This page was substantively refreshed on August 16, 2026. Company names, locations, phones, websites and policies can change after publication. Confirm every decision-making detail directly, especially credentials, ownership, availability, prices, deposits, cancellation terms and the identity of the person who will perform the work.
